COUNTERING MILITARY RECRUITMENT
Articles: Military Recruiting: Student Privacy
From marketers to the military, kids' info is in demand
Jedd Kettler, the County Courier
August 30, 2007
Information is power, and to everyone from commercial marketers anddata collection companies to military recruiters, information about
America's teenage students is not only powerful - it's essential to
reaching a lucrative market.
Those seeking the attention of the youth market gather information
from a wide variety of sources- including online and other surveys -
but one other logical stop is schools, potential gold mines of
youth-related data. And federal law often allows the release of
contact and other information these groups are looking for.
Local school officials said this week that commercial requests for
student contact information are relatively uncommon here though, and
when they do come, officials take their roles as keepers of this
information quite seriously.
"At schools we're constantly being barraged with ways to access
students ... and it may even be (for) something really good," said
Franklin West Supervisory Union Superintendent Armando Vilaseca. "Our
job is to be an education institution. It's not a way for people to
access students to make a profit."
Still, data mining is a reality in this age of information, and for
parents concerned about their children's privacy, an awareness of who
wants information and where they collect it from can be important.
The start of a new school year is the perfect time to learn.
Ultimately, the decision of what information can be released - and to
whom - is up to parents, and the first half of September is the time to do it.
Marketers & federal law meet local policy
The Family Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) - passed in 1974
with the Federal Privacy Act and the Freedom of Information Act - is
the federal law that deals with the privacy of student education records.
It applies to all schools that receive federal funding. FERPA
protections of private and educational records – transcripts, for
example – are relatively stringent, limited largely to parents and educators.
Many parents, though, are surprised to find out that more general
information about their children - names, addresses, telephone
numbers, e-mail addresses, honors and awards - can be more openly
shared under FERPA. FERPA calls this "directory information" that "is
generally not considered harmful or an invasion of privacy if released."
Mark Oettinger, the General Counsel for the Vermont Department of
Education, said, "The 'directory information' piece is the exception."
According to FERPA, directory information can be disclosed by schools
without parent consent.
The finer details are left up to local districts like Franklin County
schools, who are often much more guarded about who can get this
information. At the district level, local officials determine what
non-school groups, if any, can be given directory information.
Whether it's a local group charity group, an individual request, or a
national magazine company, local schools' policies are generally a
few steps more stringent than the federal baseline law.
"We don't provide any students' names or numbers to outside groups,"
said Enosburg Falls Principal Ed Grossman. "We're very protective."
Richford High School Principal Dale Guertin agreed: "We're just
really careful about that today ... It's a rarity to give anything out."
Missisquoi Valley Union Principal Chaunce Benedict said that few such
requests, at least from commercial or marketing entities, come into
the school. "In my view it's important ... and good that these
protections are in place, but really in my experience it's not that
common at all to see a (request)," Benedict said.
One exception is photographers looking to offer senior portraits.
MVU's policy is to release the directory information in this case.
On the other hand, the policy at Fairfax's Bellows Free Academy
specifically limits all solicitation, so any commercial request -
even on a small, local scale - is turned away.
BFA-Fairfax Principal Scott Lang pointed to a tuxedo rental company
that perennially requests directory information.
"And every year I say no," Lang said. "We really try to sugar
everything back to what our mission is, and it's about stimulating
kids academically ... We're in the education business."
Lang said he is aware of schools in other states that take a
distinctly different approach, in large part because of the need to
supplement education budgets.
Lang started his education career in Massachusetts, where "they have
schools that are selling their lists for money," he said.
No Franklin County schools raise money this way.
Military requirements
While general requests for directory information can be more closely
controlled by school policies, a request from military recruiters for
contact information is a clear - and for some a controversial - exception.
This change came about in 2002 with the passage of No Child Left
Behind. Whereas FERPA allowed local districts to release directory
information only if they so choose, NCLB required that the
information be released to military recruiters upon request. This has
led to an increase in regular annual requests from all military
branches, school officials said.
"I, in fact, have a request from a recruiter on my desk for that
information right now," said Benedict. "But I'm not going to give
that information out until our handbook has gone out ... (because
that) informs parents that - by law - that information has to be
given out to military recruiters unless parents ask that they do not."
Unless parents specifically notify school districts that they do not
want this information released to recruiters, schools are required to
provide this list.
"(Parents) have the right to opt out," Grossman said.
Schools are also required to notify parents at the beginning of the
school year of privacy and information protection policies, and in
particular to let them know of their option to block release of
directory information - whether to recruiters or anyone else.
Many print the policy prominently in student handbooks, while others
advertise the information locally.
Lang said that three years ago, after he received some complaints
that the school policy was not well-known enough by parents,
BFA-Fairfax began sending a letter directly to parents.
"My awareness got raised. And it's a fairly easy letter to write," Lang said.
This archive consists of a topically organized selection of
articles culled by members of the Counter-Recruitment List Serve from printed
publications and web sites. The archive is not complete. We have chosen
material relevant to the work of