COUNTERING MILITARY RECRUITMENT
Articles: Counter-Recruitment: General
Anti-war activists target military recruiters in Puerto Rico
The Canadian Press
September 30, 2007
MAYAGUEZ, Puerto Rico - As he walks to his recruiting station, U.S.
Army Staff Sgt. Allan Welchez Rivera averts his eyes when he passes
graffiti spray-painted across the street: "The U.S. Army: An ignorant
way to die."
As the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan drag on - and the body count of
Puerto Rican soldiers grows - an anti-recruiting campaign has emerged
in this U.S. territory of four million people. High schools have now
become a battleground for recruiters and pacifists, who have equal
access to the campuses and seek to sway island youth into joining or
shunning the military.
"I take it personal," said Welchez, a 35-year-old native of New York
City. "We're protecting the constitution, what we do everyday."
The anti-recruitment drive has energized Puerto Rico's
pro-independence movement, although only a small minority have voted
for independence in nonbinding referendums. A larger minority wants
Puerto Rico to become a U.S. state and most prefer the island keep
its loose affiliation with the U.S.
The Puerto Rican Independence Party five years ago began distributing
leaflets encouraging high school students to prevent military
recruiters from obtaining their personal information. Last year, 57
per cent of this Caribbean island's high-school sophomores, junior
and seniors signed the forms to keep their information from recruiters.
"Military service has always been the blood tax of the colony," said
Senator Maria de Lourdes Santiago of the Puerto Rican Independence
Party. "Recruiters always seek out people on the margins or in
poverty, and we have that in abundance."
Pentagon statistics show 37 service members from the island have been
killed in Iraq and Afghanistan. Anti-war groups say the figure
exceeds 80, including Puerto Ricans based on the U.S. mainland.
Wanda Colon, director of the Caribbean Project for Justice and Peace
in San Juan, which also distributes the leaflets, said recruiters
portray a soldier's life "as if it were an Indiana Jones movie."
"To fill their quotas they make promises of trips, money,
scholarships but never put them in writing because they're not real," she said.
But military recruiters deny any subterfuge, and say the military
fulfils its promises as long as recruits keep up their end of their contract.
"If we offer a bonus or an assignment, it's in black and white. We'll
guarantee that," said Sgt. 1st Class Ernesto Gonzalez, who oversees
more than a third of the 100 army recruiters in Puerto Rico.
Last September, Puerto Rico's education department gave pacifist
groups the same access to school campuses as military recruiters. The
order signed by Education Secretary Rafael Aragunde called for
students "to deliberate in a complete and informed way" when
considering a military career.
Some school districts in the U.S. have implemented similar policies
and anti-recruiting groups have distributed opt-out forms
aggressively in several major cities. But the Puerto Rico
anti-recruitment campaign has been more welcomed than efforts on the
mainland, said Pablo Paredes, an anti-war activist who has travelled
to the island and across the U.S. with the Philadelphia- based
American Friends Service Committee.
"There's not an ownership over this war. There's definitely a sense
of 'That's someone else's situation,"' he said. "In schools that
allows for a lot more fairness for groups that oppose the war."
Anti-war groups hold workshops at schools where recruiters hand out
business cards and chat with students in hallways. School directors
are required to reserve equal space for military and pacifist brochures.
Over the last four years, military enlistments from Puerto Rico have
dropped 20 per cent.
A loose network of pacifist and pro-independence groups claims the
decline as a victory, but recruiters say the opt-out leaflets have
had little impact because recruiters go after older, college-educated
candidates. Still, Welchez and Pentagon officials suspect the
anti-military campaign and an anti-war sentiment have dissuaded some
potential recruits.
Active-duty enlistments across all service branches in Puerto Rico
fell from 1,537 in 2002 to 1,229 last year, according to the
Pentagon. The army has taken the biggest hit, from 972 to 733, with
recruitment rates over the last four years below the average
per-capita contribution of mainland states.
Bill Carr, deputy undersecretary of defence for military personnel
policy, said the "tone of discouragement" is likely hurting
recruiting efforts in Puerto Rico. He said the military may spend
more on advertising to counter the activists' efforts. Nationwide,
the military currently spends about $12,000 on advertising and other
recruitment efforts per enlistee, he said.
"Supporters of a volunteer military ought to accept its duty to
describe itself to young people, and not throw obstacles in the path
of recruiters working to present those facts," Carr said in a
telephone interview from Washington.
Military recruiters here must also confront plummeting public opinion
of the Iraq war. A recent poll by the newspaper El Nuevo Dia found
that 75 per cent of islanders oppose the Iraq war. On the U.S.
mainland, 57 per cent believe going to war in Iraq was a mistake,
according to a recent Associated Press-Ipsos poll.
Every month, Mothers Against War, a Puerto Rican group, stages
protests outside the Mayaguez recruiting station in western Puerto
Rico. Sonia Santiago, leader of Mothers Against War, said she
believes the U.S. invaded Iraq and Afghanistan to secure energy
resources, not to spread democracy or protect the United States.
Despite anti-recruitment efforts, Welchez and other recruiters said
they are generally well received, but avoid going to some areas in
their military uniforms. University professors have "jumped in my
face" and told him to leave campus, he said.
Recruiters are also careful not to provoke any incidents.
After a militant independence leader died in a shootout with FBI
agents in the town of Hormigueros in 2005, recruiters were ordered by
their commanders to stay away, Welchez said.
This archive consists of a topically organized selection of articles culled by members of the Counter-Recruitment List Serve from printed publications and web sites. The archive is not complete. We have chosen material relevant to the work of Eugene, Oregon’s Committee for Countering Military Recruitment that we think may be of use to others individuals and groups with similar goals.
Because our web site is public, personal comments about the articles and (frequent) corrections of reporters’ errors are also not included. If an article interests you, we encourage you to return to the Counter-Recruitment List Serve and put the article’s headline into the search line, which should bring up (often wise and useful) commentary and corrections. If you do not belong to the List Serve, it can be found at counter-recruitment@yahoogroups.com
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the articles on this site are posted without profit to those who have expressed prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposed.